Monday Morning Debrief after the 2021 Abu Dhabi Grand Prix: Unpicking the Security Automobile interval that turned the Abu Dhabi Grand Prix on its head – and Mercedes’ protest defined

Was this probably the most dramatic and contentious conclusion of a world championship finale within the sport’s historical past? It’s actually a contender, proper up there with Brazil 2008 and Japan 1976.

Lewis Hamilton’s Mercedes dominated the occasion from the primary lap till the penultimate one, however Max Verstappen’s Crimson Bull took the victory – and thereby the championship – on the final lap below circumstances Mercedes believed have been invalid.

The controversy started on Lap 52, six from the top, when Nicholas Latifi – battling with Mick Schumacher’s Haas – crashed his Williams into the Flip 14 boundaries. At this level Hamilton was main Verstappen by 11s and was nicely on his solution to an unprecedented eighth world championship.

READ MORE: Fearless and sumptuous – Why F1’s latest champion Verstappen has proven his true colors in 2021

LBA11068_50ce11fd-1139-4cc9-b26c-4d76d8240e53 copy.jpg

Hamilton was main the race with a handful of laps to go when the Security Automobile was known as

Security Automobile. With the sphere slowed to the Security Automobile tempo, it’s the proper alternative to get onto new tyres for the restart. Except in fact you might be main the race by much less time than it could take to get into the pits, make your tyre change and speed up again out once more nonetheless main. Eleven seconds wouldn’t have been sufficient to try this. On this state of affairs, pitting Hamilton would at all times have triggered Crimson Bull into leaving Verstappen on the market, within the lead with the race virtually over.

Mercedes needed to depart Hamilton on the market – on onerous compound tyres which had been on since Lap 14. Hamilton was doubtlessly a last-gasp restart for the race and the championship along with his rival sitting proper on his gearbox on a model new set of softs. Of getting his title taken from him by random destiny.

READ MORE: ‘It was an emotional rollercoaster’ says Horner after thrilling Verstappen title win

However… it appeared prefer it may not come to that. Because the automotive and the particles have been eliminated, we have been operating out of laps. It appeared completely doable that the race would finish below the Security Automobile. Within the final couple of years there was a common settlement with the groups that the Race Director ought to at all times endeavour to have the race ending below inexperienced flag situations, even when just for a lap or two, as at Baku earlier this yr.


On the ultimate lap, Verstappen handed his rival for the lead, and the championship

On this state of affairs, that may have been unattainable to attain if regular sporting regulation protocol was adopted. By Lap 56, with two laps to go, the scene was near being cleared. On this state of affairs, lapped vehicles are often allowed to unlap themselves and the Security Automobile then pits on the finish of the next lap, giving these vehicles the possibility to hitch the again of the pack earlier than the race turns into stay. However there wasn’t time to try this. This is able to have seen the Security Automobile peeling off into the pit lane one nook from the chequered flag.

It isn’t obligatory for the lapped vehicles to be allowed to unlap themselves, however it’s on the Race Director’s discretion. On this case, it appeared that is what would occur. There have been, nevertheless, 5 lapped vehicles between Hamilton and Verstappen – these of Lando Norris, Fernando Alonso, Esteban Ocon, Charles Leclerc and Sebastian Vettel – so the ending might not have been dramatic.

So particularly the 5 lapped vehicles between Hamilton and Verstappen have been allowed to unlap themselves, and the Security Automobile could be coming in on the finish of that lap, giving one lap of racing. Hamilton’s worst fears had been realised and Verstappen duly outbraked him on his a lot gripper tyres to win each race and title.

ONBOARD: ‘Max Verstappen you’re the world champion’ – Relive the second the Crimson Bull driver claimed his 1st title

SIDE-BY-SIDE: Verstappen and Hamilton’s closing lap shootout for drivers’ title

A livid Mercedes group filed two protests, one relating to the restart process and one other which argued that Verstappen had momentarily handed Hamilton below the Security Automobile.

The primary protest was argued below article 48.12 of the sporting laws, which states:

If the clerk of the course considers it protected to take action, and the message “LAPPED CARS MAY NOW OVERTAKE” has been despatched to all Rivals by way of the official messaging system, any vehicles which have been lapped by the chief can be required to move the vehicles on the lead lap and the Security Automobile. This may solely apply to vehicles that have been lapped on the time they crossed the Line on the finish of the lap throughout which they crossed the primary Security Automobile line for the second time after the Security Automobile was deployed.

Having overtaken the vehicles on the lead lap and the Security Automobile these vehicles ought to then proceed across the observe at an applicable velocity, with out overtaking, and make each effort to take up place in the back of the road of vehicles behind the Security Automobile. While they’re overtaking, and to be able to guarantee this can be carried out safely, the vehicles on the lead lap should at all times keep on the racing line until deviating from it’s unavoidable.

Except the clerk of the course considers the presence of the Security Automobile continues to be essential, as soon as the final lapped automotive has handed the chief the Security Automobile will return to the pits on the finish of the next lap. If the clerk of the course considers observe situations are unsuitable for overtaking the message “OVERTAKING WILL NOT BE PERMITTED” can be despatched to all Rivals by way of the official messaging system.

READ MORE: Stewards dismiss Mercedes’ Abu Dhabi Grand Prix protests, as group lodge intention to attraction

LBA10772_68ae4e52-72af-4bac-adff-03aef983cf41 copy.jpg

Crimson Bull have been lastly in a position to have fun when the stewards introduced their verdict a number of hours later

The stewards threw out this attraction, arguing that article 48.12 was overridden by article 48.13, which states:

When the clerk of the course decides it’s protected to name within the Security Automobile the message “SAFETY CAR IN THIS LAP” can be despatched to all Rivals by way of the official messaging system and the automotive’s orange lights can be extinguished. This would be the sign to the Rivals and drivers that will probably be getting into the pit lane on the finish of that lap.

Having thought-about the assorted statements made by the events the Stewards decide the next:

That Article 15.3 permits the Race Director to manage the usage of the Security Automobile, which in our dedication consists of its deployment and withdrawal. That though Article 48.12 might not have been utilized totally, in relation to the Security Automobile returning to the pits on the finish of the next lap, Article 48.13 overrides that and as soon as the message “Security Automobile on this lap” has been displayed, it’s obligatory to withdraw the Security Automobile on the finish of that lap.

That however Mercedes’ request that the Stewards remediate the matter by amending the classification to mirror the positions on the finish of the penultimate lap, it is a step that the Stewards consider is successfully shortening the race retrospectively, and therefore not applicable.

READ MORE: ‘I’ve achieved every thing’ – Verstappen says additional F1 success can be ‘a bonus’ after claiming maiden title


Hamilton was gracious in defeat, after coming agonisingly near the title

Concerning the overtaking behind the Security Automobile, article 48.8 states:

Except for the circumstances listed below a) to h) under, no driver might overtake one other automotive on the observe, together with the Security Automobile, till he passes the Line (see Article 5.3) for the primary time after the Security Automobile has returned to the pits.

The stewards additionally threw out this protest on the next grounds:

Having thought-about the assorted statements made by the events. The Stewards decide that though Automobile 33 [Verstappen] did at one stage, for a really quick time frame, transfer barely in entrance of Automobile 44, at a time when each vehicles the place accelerating and braking, it moved again behind Automobile 44 [Hamilton] and it was not in entrance when the Security Automobile interval ended (i.e. on the line).

HIGHLIGHTS: Relive Hamilton and Verstappen’s dramatic combat within the Abu Dhabi GP

On such issues, the 2021 championship decider turned. And it’s a championship decider that individuals are prone to be discussing for a few years to return.

Supply hyperlink