Security Professionals and Cons of Every


  • Harnesses are often your best option for strolling canine as a result of they do not put strain on the neck.
  • However collars are typically extra comfy and have a spot to carry an ID tag.
  • It’s best to use a harness and never a collar you probably have a canine susceptible to respiratory points (like a pug). 

It doesn’t matter what kind of canine you will have, one factor’s for certain: They should exit on walks. The 2 sorts of leash attachments that you should use are harnesses and collars. 

Whether or not you simply bought a brand new canine and are not certain which to make use of otherwise you need to change issues up, it is essential to know the professionals and cons for each canine harnesses and collars earlier than making a call. 

Professionals and cons of canine harnesses


A harness straps round your canine’s chest.

cuppyuppycake/Getty Photographs

Professionals of harnesses 

Harnesses cut back pulling: Harnesses cowl the canine’s chest, shoulders, and higher again, which disperses strain over a bigger floor space than a collar supplying you with higher management over your canine, says Carly Fox, DVM, Employees Physician at New York Metropolis’s Animal Medical Heart. 

To cut back pulling even additional, you should use a no-pull harness. “When the canine pulls, the strain on the leash causes them to show again towards the proprietor. Canine can not transfer ahead except they decelerate,” says Travis Arndt, DVM, director of the Animal Medical Heart of Mid-America. 

Harnesses don’t put strain in your canine’s neck: Since harnesses fasten over the canine’s chest and never across the neck, they don’t put strain on the trachea.

This makes them ultimate for pets which have neck issues, a collapsing trachea, or restricted airways, says Arndt. A harness also can assist stop these points from arising. 

Harnesses are usually safer: Harnesses are typically higher at stopping accidents as a result of they fasten extra securely round your canine’s physique. Whereas canine can simply slip out of their collars and probably run into site visitors or one other particular person’s yard, harnesses provide far more safety and security, says Fox.

Cons of harnesses

Harnesses are much less handy: A collar can simply slip on, however harnesses take extra time to lock. 

Harnesses could not have a spot for an ID tag: Some harnesses haven’t got a spot to hold a tag. It is best to get a harness with a hoop for a tag—or use each a collar with a tag and a harness when out strolling. 

Harnesses will be uncomfortable:  Harnesses are bulkier than collars, to allow them to be extra uncomfortable in your canine. Some canine actually do not like sporting harnesses, so it may possibly take time for them to get used to strolling with one. 

When you need to use a harness

There are a number of conditions the place you need to completely be utilizing a harness over a collar. Fox says 4 conditions you need to use a harness in are:

  • In case your canine is a brachycephalic breed: Brachycephalic breed canine sometimes have flatter faces and, in consequence, respiratory points which may be higher managed with a harness. French Bulldogs and Bulldogs, are two examples. 
  • In case your canine has a historical past of tracheal collapse: This can be a medical situation the place the trachea will fold in on itself inflicting hassle respiratory and a cough.  Do not use a collar as a result of it applies additional strain and might worsen the situation.
  • When you have a breed with threat components for spinal issues: Lengthy-bodied breeds comparable to dachshunds are very susceptible to slipped disks, a situation referred to as intervertebral disc illness or (IVDD). Taking strain off the neck and again through the use of a harness may help stop additional harm.
  • When you have a big canine with a historical past of orthopedic illness: Canine with orthopedic illness can have a tough time getting as much as stroll so a harness may help you get them up and transfer round extra simply. The professionals and cons of collars

Professionals and cons of canine collars

GettyImages 660755895

A collar is worn across the canine’s neck.

Tara Gregg / EyeEm/Getty Photographs

Professionals of collars

Collars are extra handy: The primary advantage of collars is that they are often left on always, says Fox, versus a harness, which ought to solely be worn throughout walks. And even should you select to not go away your canine’s collar on always, it is nonetheless a lot simpler to snap a collar on and off than a harness.

Collars maintain ID tags: Collars sometimes include a metallic ring the place you possibly can connect your pet’s ID tag along with your handle and/or cellphone quantity in case the canine will get misplaced. 

Cons of collars

Collars will not be protected for canine with sure medical points: Keep away from utilizing collars to stroll canine with medical points comparable to glaucoma, a historical past of proptosed eye, neck accidents, or spinal malformations, says M. Leanne Lilly, DVM, DACVB, Assistant Professor of Behavioral Drugs, Veterinary Scientific Sciences, at The Ohio State College.

She says you need to verify along with your vet to see in case your canine is wholesome for a collar.

Collars will not be protected for canine that pull: In case your canine continually pulls in opposition to their collar, they’ll injure themselves or cut back the airflow they’re getting. “All collars, when hooked up to a leash, create pulling on the trachea and vertebrae of the neck. With extreme pulling there’s a threat of lowering airflow into the canine or creating ache by inflicting strain on the pet’s vertebrae,” says Arndt.

Collars shouldn’t be utilized by sure breeds: Collars shouldn’t be used on toy breeds and brachycephalic breeds, says Arndt. Examples of toy breeds embody:

  • Chihuahuas
  • Chinese language Crested
  • Italian Greyhound
  • Maltese
  • Toy Poodle
  • Yorkshire Terrier

Examples of brachycephalic breeds:

  • Bulldogs
  • French Bulldogs
  • Boston Terriers
  • Pugs
  • Boxers

When you need to use a collar

A collar could also be extra handy to make use of should you’re happening a brief stroll or stepping exterior rapidly. It’s okay to go on longer walks utilizing a collar in case your vet offers you the inexperienced gentle to take action. 

Insider’s takeaway

Whether or not you utilize a harness or a collar in your canine will depend on your canine’s well being, and in the end, your vet’s suggestion. You should definitely seek the advice of your vet to have a transparent reply on which you need to use to just be sure you hold your canine as wholesome and protected as attainable. 


Supply hyperlink